Skip to the content
Eureka The Digital Fairness Act Proposal

Chapter IV Article 34

Article 34 · Disclosure of evidence concerning commercial practices in the online environment

Open in the Reader

Part of: Enforcement and penalties

In shortEureka's summary

National courts and administrative authorities would have powers to require traders to disclose relevant evidence on the design, operation and impact on consumer behaviour of a commercial practice in the online environment. This would require a claimant to have presented facts and evidence sufficient to support the likelihood of an unfair commercial practice, or the authority to have a reasonable suspicion. Disclosure would be limited to what is necessary and proportionate.

Disclosure of evidence: online practices Under the proposal, national courts and administrative authorities would have powers to require traders to disclose, in an easily accessible and understandable manner, relevant evidence in relation to the design, operation and impact on the behaviour of consumers of a commercial practice in the online environment. Two routes, joined by "or", lead to the court: the request of a claimant that has presented facts and evidence sufficient to support the likelihood of an unfair commercial practice in the online environment, or a reasonable suspicion of the administrative authority. An arrow runs from the court to a trader with a screen; under it a folder with three tabs: design, operation, impact. Bottom left, a pair of scales: the disclosure would be limited to what is necessary and proportionate, and the protection of trade secrets is taken into account in that weighing; trade secrets are not exempt. Bottom right, a folder in dashed outline and a penalty notice: Member States would lay down rules on penalties for the failure to disclose the evidence. or claimant likelihood reasonable suspicion Court Trader Online interface disclose evidence design operation impact necessary and proportionate trade secrets Not provided failure: penalties

The act in pictures

The text of Article 34the Commission's proposal

Article 34

Disclosure of evidence concerning commercial practices in the online environment

1.In addition to the powers referred to in Article 33, national courts and administrative authorities shall have powers enabling them, in the civil or administrative proceedings referred to in Article 30 and Article 32, at the request of a claimant that has presented facts and evidence sufficient to support the likelihood of an unfair commercial practice in the online environment, or where the relevant administrative authority has a reasonable suspicion of an unfair commercial practice in the online environment, to require traders to disclose, in an easily accessible and understandable manner, relevant evidence in relation to the design, operation and impact on the behaviour of consumers of the relevant commercial practice.

National courts and administrative authorities shall have powers enabling them to impose penalties if the trader supplies incorrect, incomplete or misleading information under sub-paragraph 1 or does not supply such information within the required time-limit.

2.The disclosure of evidence pursuant to paragraph 1 shall be limited to what is necessary and proportionate.

3.When determining whether the disclosure of evidence is necessary and proportionate, national courts and administrative authorities shall consider the legitimate interest of the trader and any other party to the proceedings, in particular in relation to the protection of trade secrets.

4.Member States shall lay down the rules on penalties applicable to the failure to disclose the evidence referred to in paragraph 1. 

5.National courts or administrative authorities may consider a failure to disclose the evidence referred to in paragraph 1 as a relevant element in establishing the unfairness of a commercial practice, based on the circumstances of the case together with other relevant evidence.

Recitals that explain this article

  • Recital 85 Business-to-consumer relationships are often characterised by information asymmetries, and the necessary…

Terms defined in this act used here

  • consumer

    ‘consumer’ means any natural person who, in commercial practices covered by this Regulation, is acting for purposes which are outside that person’s trade, business, craft or profession

    Article 3, point (1)

  • trader

    ‘trader’ means any natural or legal person who, in commercial practices covered by this Regulation, is acting for purposes relating to that person’s trade, business, craft or profession and anyone acting in the name of or on behalf of a trader

    Article 3, point (2)

  • commercial practice

    ‘commercial practice’ means any act, omission, course of conduct or representation, commercial communication including advertising and marketing, by a trader, directly connected with the promotion, sale or supply of a product to consumers

    Article 3, point (3)

More in the Eureka reader

Eureka is adding links and definitions…