Dark patterns in online interfaces
Under the proposal, traders (the shop front) shall not design, organise or operate their online interfaces (the screen), including visual, auditory and other components, in a manner that is likely to deceive or manipulate consumers, or likely to otherwise materially distort the economic behaviour of consumers; the no-entry mark stands beside those words, not on the screen. Below, in its own panel: Part III of Annex I contains a list of dark patterns which would in all circumstances be regarded as unfair; the list comes in addition to the general rule. The Commission may amend that list by delegated act, by adding or modifying dark patterns, drawn as a pencil pointing at the list.
Trader
design,
organise,
operate
online interface
Prohibited
deceive or
manipulate
list: Annex I,
Part III
Amendment
Commission
may
amend
Traders would not be allowed to design, organise or operate their online interfaces in a manner likely to deceive or manipulate consumers.
Influencer marketing: disclosure
Under the proposal, three duties, each marked with a tick. Panel 1: traders carrying out influencer marketing, meaning the promotion of products in exchange for payment (a phone showing a person holding up a product, with a coin), shall disclose the commercial intent of a communication in a clear, prominent and unambiguous manner; the disclosure shall be made explicit, for each commercial communication, through the terms "advertisement" or "commercial collaboration". Panel 2: if the communication is placed on an online platform within the scope of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, the disclosure shall be made using the functionality referred to in Article 26(2) of that Regulation, drawn as a switch set to on. Panel 3: a trader using influencer marketing services (the shop front) shall ensure contractually, or in the absence of a contract through other appropriate means, that the trader carrying out the influencer marketing complies with the Regulation, drawn as a contract between the two.
Influencer
advertisement
or
commercial collaboration
each communication
if: online platform
Influencer
platform functionality
Trader
Contract
Influencer
ensure contractually
Traders carrying out influencer marketing would have to mark each commercial communication with the term ‘advertisement’ or ‘commercial collaboration’.
Influencer marketing: five prohibitions
Under the proposal, traders carrying out influencer marketing, meaning the promotion of products in exchange for payment (top left: a megaphone and a phone showing a person holding up a product, with a coin), shall not do five things, each drawn as a tile with a no-entry mark. They shall not include direct exhortations to minors to buy products or to persuade their parents or other adults to buy products; create the impression that they are not acting for commercial purposes when they are, in particular when the communications are carried out by or feature minors; or create the impression that a product is appropriate for minors when it is not. They shall not carry out influencer marketing of products prohibited from being advertised to consumers under Union or national law, nor of products that are dangerous within the meaning of Regulation (EU) 2023/988 or other Union product legislation. A minor is any natural person under the age of 18.
Commercial practice
Influencer
Prohibited
under 18
direct
exhortations
to minors
Prohibited
impression:
not commercial
Prohibited
under 18
impression:
appropriate
for minors
Prohibited
prohibited
from being
advertised
Prohibited
dangerous
products
Influencer marketing would be barred from five things, among them direct exhortations to minors to buy and the marketing of dangerous products.
Profiling-based advertising: two limits Under the proposal, traders would not be allowed to target advertisements to a consumer based on profiling in two cases, drawn as two panels with a no-entry mark, below a row showing profiling leading to targeted advertisements shown to a consumer. First: by using personal data of the consumer, if the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor (a person under 18). Second: by using special categories of personal data referred to in Article 9(1) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679. Other advertising is not covered by this rule. Traders would not have to process additional personal data to assess whether the consumer is a minor. The article would not apply to providers of online platforms to whom Section 3 of Chapter III of Regulation 2022/2065 applies.
profiling target advertisements
Consumer
if: aware with reasonable certainty
under 18
personal data Prohibited
Prohibited
special categories
not for: online platforms
Traders would not be allowed to target advertisements based on profiling by using the personal data of a consumer where they are aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor, or by using special categories of personal data.
Personalised pricing: two limits Under the proposal, traders would not be allowed to personalise the price based on profiling in a manner that is reasonably likely to cause harm to the consumer, where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor (a person under 18), or is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is vulnerable due to their age, credulity, disability, or any specific misfortune or circumstance of such gravity as to impair the consumer’s judgment. Drawn as: a profile leading to a price tag marked with a person, beside a cracked coin for harm; an arrow with a no-entry mark leads down to a panel that carries the condition and shows a minor and a vulnerable consumer. All conditions must be met together; other personalised pricing is not covered by this rule. Traders would not have to process additional personal data to assess whether a consumer is a minor or vulnerable.
profiling
Harm
personalise the price likely to cause harm
Prohibited
if: aware with reasonable certainty
under 18
vulnerable
Traders would not be allowed to personalise the price based on profiling in a manner reasonably likely to cause harm where they are aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor or vulnerable.
Virtual currencies: value and minors Two rules of the proposal. First panel: a trader offering paid-for virtual currencies that are used to purchase virtual items or other products offered by that trader would have to indicate the corresponding monetary value of those virtual items or other products, or their estimated monetary value in the currency in which the consumer acquired the first virtual currency. Drawn as a coin, an arrow to a virtual item, and a banknote with a tick attached to the item. Second panel: where a trader’s products are directed at minors, or where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors (persons under 18), paid-for virtual currencies would have to be disabled by default for minors and could only be activated upon parent or guardian approval. Drawn as a minor, the coin with a switch set to off, and a parent holding a key towards the switch. The first rule would not apply to certain providers subject to the disclosure obligation in Article 13(1) of Regulation (EU) [EU KIDS Act].
paid-for virtual currencies
monetary value
if: directed at minors
or: aware with reasonable certainty
under 18
disabled by default
parent or guardian approval
Traders would have to show the monetary value of what paid-for virtual currencies buy and, for minors, keep those currencies switched off unless a parent or guardian approves.
Variable reward systems: three rules Three rules of the proposal on paid-for variable reward systems (virtual items, other than financial products, offering random rewards or variable odds), drawn as a closed box with a question mark. First panel: traders offering them would have to inform consumers about the types of products or virtual items available in such systems and the probability of obtaining them; drawn as three different items, each beside a bar of a different length, without figures. Second panel: traders would have to make available, in an easily accessible manner, effective tools enabling consumers to disable paid-for variable reward systems; drawn as the box beside a switch set to off. Third panel: where a trader’s products are directed at minors, or where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors (persons under 18), the trader would not be allowed to offer paid-for variable reward systems to minors; drawn as an arrow from the box to a minor with a no-entry mark on it. The third rule would not apply to certain providers that are subject to Article 13(2) of Regulation (EU) [EU KIDS Act].
paid-for variable reward systems
types probability
tools to disable
if: directed at minors
or: aware with reasonable certainty
Variable reward system
Prohibited
under 18
Traders would have to state what paid-for variable reward systems contain and the probability of obtaining it, offer a tool to disable them, and not offer them to minors under the stated condition.
Pay-to-progress and pay-to-win: minors Under the proposal, where a trader’s products are directed at minors, or where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors (persons under 18), the trader would not be allowed to offer pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms to minors. These are in-game or in-app purchases that are necessary, or are presented as necessary, for in-game or in-app progress or success. Drawn as: the condition in a strip; a row of steps with a closed gate that takes a coin (pay-to-progress); a winner’s podium with a coin under the top step (pay-to-win); and an arrow from both to a minor with a no-entry mark on it. Other purchases are not covered by this rule.
if: directed at minors
or: aware with reasonable certainty
Virtual currency
pay-to-progress
Virtual currency
pay-to-win
Prohibited
under 18
Under the stated condition, traders would not be allowed to offer pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms to minors.
Addictive design: tools to disable Under the proposal, traders that design, organise or operate their digital products in a manner that is intended, or can reasonably be foreseen, to encourage compulsive or excessive use would have to make available to consumers, in an easily accessible manner, effective tools enabling them to disable, individually or all at once, four kinds of features that encourage such use. Drawn as a settings list with a tick (the tool is what the trader must provide) and a switch for each feature, some on and some off, plus one switch for all: features enabling automatic play of content and uninterrupted content consumption without effective and regular interruption moments; notifications not triggered by, or not directly related to, the consumer’s interaction or activity on the service; features incentivising engagement at regular times or with greater frequency; and features and system behaviours that encourage continued use by simulating interpersonal relations, such as persistent prompts to continue engaging with an automated system. The features themselves would not be prohibited by this article. The article would not apply to certain traders covered by Regulation (EU) [EU KIDS Act].
if: compulsive or excessive use
disable individually
automatic play
notifications
engagement at regular times
simulating interpersonal relations
or all at once
Where a digital product is designed in a way that encourages compulsive or excessive use, the trader would have to give consumers tools to disable four kinds of features.
Event tickets: price transparency Two disclosure rules of the proposal for event tickets; neither sets or caps a price. First panel: in an invitation to purchase event tickets the price of which is liable to increase due to the trader’s actions or due to automated or algorithmic processes, the trader would have to clearly and prominently disclose how many tickets in the relevant ticket category are available at the advertised price, and the maximum price a consumer may be required to pay for that ticket. Drawn as a ticket beside a display with two ticked items; the maximum price is shown as a price tag beside an arrow stopping at a line. Second panel: a trader offering resale of an event ticket would have to clearly and prominently display the original total price of the ticket charged by the event organiser and, where applicable, the ticket category, row and seat number. Drawn as a ticket being passed on, beside a display with two ticked items.
if: price liable to increase
Ticket
how many tickets at advertised price
maximum price
resale
original total price
category, row, seat
Sellers of event tickets whose price may rise would have to show how many tickets are available at the advertised price and the maximum price; resellers would have to show the original total price.
Virtual queue: price on display Under the proposal, where a trader makes use of a virtual queue system (a sequenced waiting system before the ordering interface, during which the trader could change the price), the trader would have to display clearly and prominently, at the moment when the consumer enters the virtual queue and for as long as the consumer is in it: the current price of the product, updated in real time where the price varies during the consumer’s time in the queue; whether that price is subject to variation during the waiting time; and, where the price may vary, the maximum price the consumer may be required to pay. Drawn as a display board with three ticked items above a line of people waiting for a screen. The rule is about display only: it would not freeze the price or prohibit price changes. The article would not apply to the execution of orders on financial instruments pursuant to Regulation (EU) No 600/2014.
current price real time
subject to variation
maximum price
in the queue
Online interface
virtual queue
not for: financial instruments
A trader using a virtual queue would have to show, for as long as the consumer is in it, the current price, whether it may vary and the maximum price.
Free trials: reminder and agreement A timeline, not to scale, for contracts with a free trial period concluded by means of an online interface or by other digital means. Under the proposal the trader would have to send the consumer a reminder on a durable medium within a reasonable period before the end of the trial period (drawn as an envelope with a tick before the end date), stating the end date, the right to terminate and the possibility to continue on a paid basis if the consumer expressly agrees. At the end date the line forks. If the reminder has been sent and the consumer has expressly agreed before the end of the trial, the contract continues as a paid contract and the trader would have to provide a confirmation of that agreement on a durable medium without undue delay and at the latest within a week (second envelope with a tick). If the reminder has not been sent, or the consumer has not expressly agreed, the consumer would not be bound by the contract: either one is enough, drawn as two separate arrows, one from a dashed envelope and one from a dashed speech bubble, to an open chain link.
end date free trial Message sent
Message sent
reasonable period before
expressly agrees
paid contract
confirmation
within a week
Not provided
Not provided
not bound
Before a free trial ends the trader would have to send a reminder, and the consumer would be bound to a paid contract only after expressly agreeing.
Long contracts: reminder before extension Three timelines, not to scale, for a contract for the continuous supply of products with a duration of six months or longer, concluded by means of an online interface or by other digital means, that provides for an automatic extension. First panel: under the proposal the trader would have to remind the consumer on a durable medium, no earlier than 1 month and no later than fourteen days before the date on which the contract is automatically extended, of the upcoming extension and the right to terminate; drawn as an envelope with a tick over a shaded window before the extension. Second panel: where the reminder has not been sent (dashed envelope), the contract is still extended, but the consumer would have the right to terminate free of charge at any time from the date of extension until the date the trader sends a reminder, without any notice period. Third panel: for contracts that have been extended for an indeterminate duration, the consumer would have the right to terminate at any time after the automatic extension with a maximum one-month notice period and free of charge, except for the charges for receiving the product during the notice period; this applies whether or not a reminder was sent.
six months or longer
automatic extension
Message sent
Message sent
1 month fourteen days before
Not provided
terminate free of charge
indeterminate duration
maximum one-monthnotice
For contracts of six months or longer, the trader would have to send a reminder no earlier than 1 month and no later than fourteen days before an automatic extension.
Short contracts: reminder before extension A timeline, not to scale and without a real number of periods, for a contract for the continuous supply of products with a duration of less than six months, concluded by means of an online interface or by other digital means, that provides for an automatic extension. Under the proposal the trader would have to remind the consumer on a durable medium of the upcoming extension and the right to terminate at the latest one week before the automatic extension which either results in the initial contract duration (or any subsequent extension period) reaching six months or constitutes the tenth extension of the contract, whichever occurs earlier. Drawn as a row of equal periods with two flags, one where the running time reaches six months and one at the tenth extension, a bracket pointing to the earlier flag, and an envelope with a tick one week before it. Which flag comes first depends on the contract; the drawing follows one reading of an unclear sentence. Second panel: where the reminder has not been sent (dashed envelope), the consumer would have the right to terminate free of charge at any time from the date that the reminder was due until the date the trader sends a reminder. A derogation for short-term investment contracts, where the consumer has given explicit consent, is not drawn.
whichever occurs earlier
reach six months
tenth extension less than six months
Message sent
Message sent
one week before
Not provided
terminate free of charge
For contracts of less than six months, a reminder would be due at the latest one week before the extension that reaches six months or is the tenth extension, whichever occurs earlier.
Online contract termination function Four numbered steps. Under the proposal, where a trader offers consumers the possibility of concluding contracts by means of an online interface, the trader would have to ensure that consumers can terminate the contract by using a contract termination function on the online interface, irrespective of the manner in which the contract was concluded. Step 1: the function would be labelled with the words ‘terminate the contract here’ or an unambiguous corresponding formulation, prominently displayed and easily accessible; drawn as a button on a screen, with a tick. Step 2: it would enable the consumer to send an online contract termination statement with the consumer’s name, details identifying the contract, and details of the electronic means by which the acknowledgement will be sent; drawn as a form with three lines. Step 3: the consumer would submit it by means of a confirmation function labelled only with the words ‘confirm the contract termination’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation. Step 4: the trader would have to send the consumer an acknowledgement of receipt on a durable medium without undue delay, and at the latest within a week. The article concerns how to terminate, not whether or when a contract can be ended.
if: contracts concluded online
1
terminate the contract here
Required
2
Consumer
Contract
Electronic mail
termination statement
3
confirm the contract termination
4
Trader
Consumer
acknowledgement
within a week
A trader that lets consumers conclude contracts online would have to offer an online function to terminate them, labelled ‘terminate the contract here’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation.
Online withdrawal function Four numbered steps. Under the proposal, for distance contracts within the meaning of Article 2, point (7) of Directive 2011/83/EU, including contracts for the supply of financial services, concluded by means of an online interface, the trader would have to ensure that the consumer can withdraw from the contract by using a withdrawal function. Step 1: the function would be labelled with the words ‘withdraw from contract here’ or an unambiguous corresponding formulation, prominently displayed, easily accessible and continuously available during the withdrawal period; drawn as a button on a screen, with a tick, over a bracket for the withdrawal period. Step 2: it would enable the consumer to send an online withdrawal statement with the consumer’s name, details identifying the contract, and details of the electronic means by which the acknowledgement will be sent; drawn as a form with three lines. Step 3: the consumer would submit it by means of a confirmation function labelled only with the words ‘confirm withdrawal’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation. Step 4: the trader would have to send the consumer an acknowledgement of receipt on a durable medium without undue delay; this article sets no limit in days or weeks. The right of withdrawal and its length come from Directive 2011/83/EU, not from this article.
if: distance contracts concluded online
1
withdraw from contract here
Required
withdrawal period
2
Consumer
Contract
Electronic mail
withdrawal statement
3
confirm withdrawal
4
Trader
Consumer
acknowledgement without undue delay
For distance contracts concluded online, the trader would have to offer a withdrawal function labelled ‘withdraw from contract here’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation, available throughout the withdrawal period.
A human being in customer service
Under the proposal, where a trader provides online customer service after the conclusion of a contract, the trader would have to ensure that communication with a human being is made available. Two conditions are drawn in one box and joined by the word "and": the consumer asks for it (upon request of the consumer), and other means are not effective. The other means are drawn as an automated system and a message with a broken grey line under them; the text does not limit them to automated systems. An arrow leads from the box to a person with a headset and a tick: a human being. A strip at the bottom says the article would not apply to investment services as defined in point (2) of Article 4(1) of Directive 2014/65/EU.
if: online customer service
Contract
upon request
and
other means
not effective
Required
human being
not for: investment services
Where a trader provides online customer service after a contract is concluded, it would have to make communication with a human being available on request when other means are not effective.
Automated systems: the consumer's choice
Under the proposal, traders making available automated systems that consumers can use to conclude and perform contracts on their behalf would have to ensure that, on the first use, consumers are required to expressly choose one of three options. The picture shows a consumer, an automated system holding a contract, and a card headed "first use" with three equal options, none of them pre-selected: confirm all contracts proposed by the system before being bound; confirm only a certain type of contracts, based on criteria set by the consumer, including a maximum price and a time limit (drawn as a price tag under a line and a clock); or no confirmation of contracts before being bound. A tick marks the trader's duty. Below: consumers could modify the choice at any time, and the trader would have to send a confirmation of the choice on a durable medium. A strip at the bottom says the article would not apply to the provision of financial services.
Consumer
Automated system
first use
Required
confirm all contracts
confirm certain type
no confirmation
modify at any time
confirmation
of choice
not for: financial services
On first use of an automated system that concludes contracts on their behalf, consumers would have to choose expressly whether to confirm all contracts, only a certain type, or none.
Automated systems: further safeguards
Under the proposal, three panels. First panel: if a payment was received by the trader making the automated system available for proposing a contract, or if there is a conflict of interest with the traders concerned by a proposed contract, the automated system would have to disclose it and require the consumer to confirm the corresponding contract, independently of the choice the consumer expressed earlier. Second panel: where the automated system concludes a contract with a trader, it would transmit to that trader the consumer's contact details necessary for the performance of the contract, and that trader would have to send the consumer a confirmation of the contract on a durable medium, in plain and intelligible language. Third panel, with a no-entry mark: traders would not be allowed to design, organise or operate their online interfaces in a way that requires consumers to use automated systems to access them or to conclude commercial transactions on them; the mark sits on the requirement, not on the automated system. A strip at the bottom says the article would not apply to the provision of financial services.
if: payment received
or: conflict of interest
Trader
Automated system
disclose
consumer
to confirm
Automated system
Trader
Consumer
contact details
contract confirmation
Consumer
Automated system
Prohibited
requiring
automated systems
not for: financial services
Automated systems would have to disclose payments and conflicts of interest, traders would have to confirm the contracts concluded, and no trader could make consumers use an automated system.
Contracts concluded solely through automated systems
Under the proposal, where a contract is concluded by the trader and by the consumer solely through automated systems, the trader would be allowed to provide the information referred to in Article 6(1) of Directive 2011/83/EU only in a commonly used machine-readable format. This permission is drawn as a file with curly brackets travelling from the trader's automated system to the consumer's automated system, marked with the word "may". A second arrow runs from the trader over both systems to the consumer in person and carries an envelope with a tick: the trader would have to provide the consumer with the confirmation of the contract on a durable medium, in plain and intelligible language.
if: solely through automated systems
Contract
durable medium
plain and intelligible language
Consumer
Trader
Automated system
Automated system
may
machine-readable format
Where a contract is concluded solely through automated systems, the trader could give the pre-contractual information in machine-readable format only, but would have to confirm the contract to the consumer in plain language.
Direct marketing: consent first
Under the proposal, three panels about direct marketing. First panel, with a no-entry mark: traders would not be allowed to use automated calling systems without human intervention (automatic calling machines), SMS, MMS or electronic mail for direct marketing without the consumer's prior consent. Second panel, linked to the electronic mail icon only, the exception: where a trader obtains electronic mail contact details from its customers in the context of the sale or supply of a product, that trader may use them for direct marketing of its own similar products, provided that consumers are clearly given the opportunity to object, free of charge and in an easy manner, at the time of collection and with each message. Third panel, with a no-entry mark: traders would not be allowed to call a consumer for direct marketing by other communication systems without the consumer's prior consent or, where the national law of the Member State of the consumer's residence so provides, where the consumer has opted out; the picture repeats the "or" of the text and does not resolve it. Bottom strip: every direct marketing electronic mail would have to indicate a valid electronic mail address to which the recipient may send a request that the messages cease.
direct marketing
Phone call
Automated system
SMS
MMS
Electronic mail
Prohibited
Consumer
without
prior consent
Trader
Consumer
may
Electronic mail
own similar
products
opportunity
to object
Phone call
Human being
Prohibited
Consumer
without
prior consent
or: opted out
valid electronic mail address
Traders would need the consumer's prior consent for direct marketing by automatic calling machines, SMS, MMS or electronic mail, with one exception for their own customers.
No way round Chapter III
Under the proposal, traders would not be allowed to engage in any conduct that undermines effective compliance with their obligations in Chapter III. The obligations are drawn as a wall; a trader follows a dashed path round the wall, and a no-entry mark sits on that path. Below, five kinds of conduct the article names: contractual, commercial, technical, the use of behavioural techniques, and interface design. A sixth, dashed tile with three dots stands for "or any other nature": the list is not closed.
Trader
Prohibited
obligations in Chapter III
contractual
commercial
technical
behavioural
techniques
interface
design
Traders would not be allowed to engage in any conduct that undermines effective compliance with their obligations in Chapter III.