Skip to the content
Eureka The Digital Fairness Act Proposal

Topics

Dark patterns

Eureka's summary

Article 10 would prohibit traders from designing, organising or operating their online interfaces in a manner likely to deceive or manipulate consumers. Part III of Annex I lists dark patterns that would be regarded as unfair in all circumstances. The points below give the general rule and some of the listed practices.

What counts as unfair Under the proposal, unfair commercial practices would be prohibited. A practice would be unfair if it is contrary to the requirements of professional diligence and materially distorts, or is likely to materially distort, the economic behaviour of the average consumer. Four named cases are shown as tiles: misleading practices, aggressive practices, a breach of an obligation in Chapter III, and the practices listed in Annex I, which are regarded as unfair in all circumstances. unfair commercial practices: prohibited contrary to professional diligence and distorts economic behaviour misleading aggressive breach ofChapter III Annex I:unfair in allcircumstances
One general prohibition, with misleading practices, aggressive practices, breaches of Chapter III and the Annex I list as the named cases. The act in pictures

Article 10 · Dark patterns

Traders would not be allowed to design, organise or operate their online interfaces in a manner that is likely to deceive or manipulate consumers, or to otherwise materially distort the economic behaviour of consumers. Part III of Annex I lists dark patterns regarded as unfair in all circumstances. The Commission could add to or modify that list by delegated act.

Dark patterns in online interfaces Under the proposal, traders (the shop front) shall not design, organise or operate their online interfaces (the screen), including visual, auditory and other components, in a manner that is likely to deceive or manipulate consumers, or likely to otherwise materially distort the economic behaviour of consumers; the no-entry mark stands beside those words, not on the screen. Below, in its own panel: Part III of Annex I contains a list of dark patterns which would in all circumstances be regarded as unfair; the list comes in addition to the general rule. The Commission may amend that list by delegated act, by adding or modifying dark patterns, drawn as a pencil pointing at the list. Trader design, organise, operate online interface Prohibited deceive or manipulate list: Annex I, Part III Amendment Commission may amend
Traders would not be allowed to design, organise or operate their online interfaces in a manner likely to deceive or manipulate consumers. The act in pictures

Read Article 10

Article 29 · Anti-circumvention

Traders would not be allowed to engage in any conduct that undermines effective compliance with their obligations in Chapter III. This would apply regardless of whether the conduct is of a contractual, commercial, technical or any other nature, or consists in the use of behavioural techniques or interface design.

No way round Chapter III Under the proposal, traders would not be allowed to engage in any conduct that undermines effective compliance with their obligations in Chapter III. The obligations are drawn as a wall; a trader follows a dashed path round the wall, and a no-entry mark sits on that path. Below, five kinds of conduct the article names: contractual, commercial, technical, the use of behavioural techniques, and interface design. A sixth, dashed tile with three dots stands for "or any other nature": the list is not closed. Trader Prohibited obligations in Chapter III contractual commercial technical behavioural techniques interface design
Traders would not be allowed to engage in any conduct that undermines effective compliance with their obligations in Chapter III. The act in pictures

Read Article 29

Recitals

  1. 51
  2. 52
  3. 119
  4. 120
  5. 121
  6. 122
Eureka is adding links and definitions…