Skip to the content
Eureka The Digital Fairness Act Proposal

Topics

Minors

Eureka's summary

The proposal has no single article on minors. A ‘minor’ or ‘child’ is defined as any natural person under the age of 18, and rules that name minors or children are spread over Articles 11 to 17 and Annex I. Several of them apply where the trader's products are directed at minors or where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors.

Article 3 · Definitions

This article defines 34 terms used in the Regulation. They include ‘consumer’, ‘trader’, ‘commercial practice’, ‘product’ and ‘transactional decision’, and terms such as ‘online interface’, ‘influencer marketing’, ‘virtual queue’ and ‘automated system’. A ‘minor’ or ‘child’ would mean any natural person under the age of 18.

Read Article 3

Article 11 · Influencer marketing

Traders carrying out influencer marketing would have to disclose the commercial intent of each commercial communication through the terms ‘advertisement’ or ‘commercial collaboration’. They could not directly exhort minors to buy products, nor carry out influencer marketing of products that may not be advertised under Union or national law or that are dangerous. Traders using influencer marketing services would have to ensure compliance contractually or by other appropriate means.

Influencer marketing: disclosure Under the proposal, three duties, each marked with a tick. Panel 1: traders carrying out influencer marketing, meaning the promotion of products in exchange for payment (a phone showing a person holding up a product, with a coin), shall disclose the commercial intent of a communication in a clear, prominent and unambiguous manner; the disclosure shall be made explicit, for each commercial communication, through the terms "advertisement" or "commercial collaboration". Panel 2: if the communication is placed on an online platform within the scope of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, the disclosure shall be made using the functionality referred to in Article 26(2) of that Regulation, drawn as a switch set to on. Panel 3: a trader using influencer marketing services (the shop front) shall ensure contractually, or in the absence of a contract through other appropriate means, that the trader carrying out the influencer marketing complies with the Regulation, drawn as a contract between the two. Influencer advertisement or commercial collaboration each communication if: online platform Influencer platform functionality Trader Contract Influencer ensure contractually
Traders carrying out influencer marketing would have to mark each commercial communication with the term ‘advertisement’ or ‘commercial collaboration’. The act in pictures
Influencer marketing: five prohibitions Under the proposal, traders carrying out influencer marketing, meaning the promotion of products in exchange for payment (top left: a megaphone and a phone showing a person holding up a product, with a coin), shall not do five things, each drawn as a tile with a no-entry mark. They shall not include direct exhortations to minors to buy products or to persuade their parents or other adults to buy products; create the impression that they are not acting for commercial purposes when they are, in particular when the communications are carried out by or feature minors; or create the impression that a product is appropriate for minors when it is not. They shall not carry out influencer marketing of products prohibited from being advertised to consumers under Union or national law, nor of products that are dangerous within the meaning of Regulation (EU) 2023/988 or other Union product legislation. A minor is any natural person under the age of 18. Commercial practice Influencer Prohibited under 18 direct exhortations to minors Prohibited impression: not commercial Prohibited under 18 impression: appropriate for minors Prohibited prohibited from being advertised Prohibited dangerous products
Influencer marketing would be barred from five things, among them direct exhortations to minors to buy and the marketing of dangerous products. The act in pictures

Read Article 11

Article 12 · Personalised advertising

Traders would not be allowed to target advertisements to a consumer based on profiling by using the consumer's personal data where they are aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor, or by using special categories of personal data. Providers of online platforms to whom Section 3 of Chapter III of Regulation 2022/2065 applies are excluded.

Profiling-based advertising: two limitsUnder the proposal, traders would not be allowed to target advertisements to a consumer based on profiling in two cases, drawn as two panels with a no-entry mark, below a row showing profiling leading to targeted advertisements shown to a consumer. First: by using personal data of the consumer, if the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor (a person under 18). Second: by using special categories of personal data referred to in Article 9(1) of Regulation (EU) 2016/679. Other advertising is not covered by this rule. Traders would not have to process additional personal data to assess whether the consumer is a minor. The article would not apply to providers of online platforms to whom Section 3 of Chapter III of Regulation 2022/2065 applies. profilingtarget advertisements Consumer if: aware with reasonable certainty under 18 personal dataProhibited Prohibited specialcategories not for: online platforms
Traders would not be allowed to target advertisements based on profiling by using the personal data of a consumer where they are aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor, or by using special categories of personal data. The act in pictures

Read Article 12

Article 13 · Personalised pricing

Traders would not be allowed to personalise the price based on profiling in a manner that is reasonably likely to cause harm to the consumer, where they are aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor or is vulnerable due to age, credulity, disability, or any specific misfortune or circumstance of such gravity as to impair the consumer's judgment.

Personalised pricing: two limitsUnder the proposal, traders would not be allowed to personalise the price based on profiling in a manner that is reasonably likely to cause harm to the consumer, where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor (a person under 18), or is aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is vulnerable due to their age, credulity, disability, or any specific misfortune or circumstance of such gravity as to impair the consumer’s judgment. Drawn as: a profile leading to a price tag marked with a person, beside a cracked coin for harm; an arrow with a no-entry mark leads down to a panel that carries the condition and shows a minor and a vulnerable consumer. All conditions must be met together; other personalised pricing is not covered by this rule. Traders would not have to process additional personal data to assess whether a consumer is a minor or vulnerable. profiling Harm personalise the pricelikely to cause harm Prohibited if: aware with reasonable certainty under 18 vulnerable
Traders would not be allowed to personalise the price based on profiling in a manner reasonably likely to cause harm where they are aware with reasonable certainty that the consumer is a minor or vulnerable. The act in pictures

Read Article 13

Article 14 · Virtual currencies

A trader offering paid-for virtual currencies used to purchase its virtual items or other products would have to indicate the monetary value, or estimated monetary value, of those items or products. Where its products are directed at minors, or it is aware with reasonable certainty that minors use the product, paid-for virtual currencies would be disabled by default for minors and activated only upon parent or guardian approval.

Virtual currencies: value and minorsTwo rules of the proposal. First panel: a trader offering paid-for virtual currencies that are used to purchase virtual items or other products offered by that trader would have to indicate the corresponding monetary value of those virtual items or other products, or their estimated monetary value in the currency in which the consumer acquired the first virtual currency. Drawn as a coin, an arrow to a virtual item, and a banknote with a tick attached to the item. Second panel: where a trader’s products are directed at minors, or where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors (persons under 18), paid-for virtual currencies would have to be disabled by default for minors and could only be activated upon parent or guardian approval. Drawn as a minor, the coin with a switch set to off, and a parent holding a key towards the switch. The first rule would not apply to certain providers subject to the disclosure obligation in Article 13(1) of Regulation (EU) [EU KIDS Act]. paid-forvirtual currencies monetary value if: directed at minors or: aware with reasonable certainty under 18 disabled by default parent or guardianapproval
Traders would have to show the monetary value of what paid-for virtual currencies buy and, for minors, keep those currencies switched off unless a parent or guardian approves. The act in pictures

Read Article 14

Article 15 · Variable reward systems

Traders offering paid-for variable reward systems would have to inform consumers about the types of products or virtual items available in them and the probability of obtaining them. They would have to make available easily accessible, effective tools to disable such systems. Where their products are directed at minors, or they are aware with reasonable certainty that minors use the product, they could not offer such systems to minors.

Variable reward systems: three rulesThree rules of the proposal on paid-for variable reward systems (virtual items, other than financial products, offering random rewards or variable odds), drawn as a closed box with a question mark. First panel: traders offering them would have to inform consumers about the types of products or virtual items available in such systems and the probability of obtaining them; drawn as three different items, each beside a bar of a different length, without figures. Second panel: traders would have to make available, in an easily accessible manner, effective tools enabling consumers to disable paid-for variable reward systems; drawn as the box beside a switch set to off. Third panel: where a trader’s products are directed at minors, or where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors (persons under 18), the trader would not be allowed to offer paid-for variable reward systems to minors; drawn as an arrow from the box to a minor with a no-entry mark on it. The third rule would not apply to certain providers that are subject to Article 13(2) of Regulation (EU) [EU KIDS Act]. paid-for variable reward systems typesprobability tools to disable if: directed at minors or: aware with reasonable certainty Variable reward system Prohibited under 18
Traders would have to state what paid-for variable reward systems contain and the probability of obtaining it, offer a tool to disable them, and not offer them to minors under the stated condition. The act in pictures

Read Article 15

Article 16 · Prohibition of pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms for minors

Traders would not be allowed to offer pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms to minors where their products are directed at minors or where they are aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors.

Pay-to-progress and pay-to-win: minorsUnder the proposal, where a trader’s products are directed at minors, or where the trader is aware with reasonable certainty that the product is used by minors (persons under 18), the trader would not be allowed to offer pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms to minors. These are in-game or in-app purchases that are necessary, or are presented as necessary, for in-game or in-app progress or success. Drawn as: the condition in a strip; a row of steps with a closed gate that takes a coin (pay-to-progress); a winner’s podium with a coin under the top step (pay-to-win); and an arrow from both to a minor with a no-entry mark on it. Other purchases are not covered by this rule. if: directed at minors or: aware with reasonable certainty Virtual currency pay-to-progress Virtual currency pay-to-win Prohibited under 18
Under the stated condition, traders would not be allowed to offer pay-to-progress and pay-to-win mechanisms to minors. The act in pictures

Read Article 16

Article 17 · Addictive design

Traders that design, organise or operate their digital products in a manner that is intended, or can reasonably be foreseen, to encourage compulsive or excessive use would have to give consumers easily accessible, effective tools to disable four listed features. These include automatic play of content, notifications not triggered by the consumer's activity, and features simulating interpersonal relations. The Commission could add to or modify the list by delegated act.

Addictive design: tools to disableUnder the proposal, traders that design, organise or operate their digital products in a manner that is intended, or can reasonably be foreseen, to encourage compulsive or excessive use would have to make available to consumers, in an easily accessible manner, effective tools enabling them to disable, individually or all at once, four kinds of features that encourage such use. Drawn as a settings list with a tick (the tool is what the trader must provide) and a switch for each feature, some on and some off, plus one switch for all: features enabling automatic play of content and uninterrupted content consumption without effective and regular interruption moments; notifications not triggered by, or not directly related to, the consumer’s interaction or activity on the service; features incentivising engagement at regular times or with greater frequency; and features and system behaviours that encourage continued use by simulating interpersonal relations, such as persistent prompts to continue engaging with an automated system. The features themselves would not be prohibited by this article. The article would not apply to certain traders covered by Regulation (EU) [EU KIDS Act]. if: compulsive or excessive use disableindividually automatic play notifications engagement at regular times simulating interpersonalrelations or all at once
Where a digital product is designed in a way that encourages compulsive or excessive use, the trader would have to give consumers tools to disable four kinds of features. The act in pictures

Read Article 17

Article 30 · Enforcement

Member States would have to ensure adequate and effective means to ensure compliance, including action by persons or organisations with a legitimate interest, including competitors, before courts and/or administrative authorities. These could order the cessation of unfair commercial practices or prohibit imminent ones. The Commission would have powers to investigate and enforce with regard to widespread infringements with a Union dimension, subject to listed exceptions.

Who can act against unfair practices Under the proposal, persons or organisations regarded under national law as having a legitimate interest in combating unfair commercial practices, including competitors, may take legal action against such practices and/or bring them before an administrative authority; each Member State would decide which of these means is available. Courts or administrative authorities would have powers to order the cessation of unfair commercial practices and, if a practice has not yet been carried out but is imminent, to order its prohibition, even without proof of actual loss or damage or of intention or negligence on the part of the trader. The picture shows a group of people and a business building at the top, two arrows to a court and to an administrative authority with a flag between them, and below them a box with two orders. legitimate interest including competitors Member State decides legal action administrative authority and/or cessation imminent: prohibition without proof of loss
Persons and organisations with a legitimate interest, including competitors, could go to court or to an administrative authority, which could order unfair practices to stop. The act in pictures
Special enforcement routes Under the proposal, four special enforcement routes, each drawn as a separate row; the rows are not a complete map of who enforces the Regulation. Row 1: the Commission would have powers to investigate and enforce compliance with regard to widespread infringements with a Union dimension, as defined in Regulation (EU) [New CPC Regulation], except for the matters in Article 2(3), (4), (7) and (8) and Article 28(3). Row 2: Articles 14(2), 15(3) and 16, the provisions on minors, would be enforced by the competent authorities designated under Regulation (EU) [EU KIDS Act], only for traders within the scope of that Regulation and under the conditions it stipulates. Row 3: Article 17(1) would be enforced by the authorities designated under Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 for traders that are providers of online platforms. Row 4: Article 17(1) would be enforced by the authorities designated under Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 for traders that are providers or deployers of AI systems within its scope. widespread infringements Union dimension Commission under 18 Articles 14(2), 15(3), 16 EU KIDS Act authorities Article 17(1) online platforms Regulation (EU) 2022/2065 Article 17(1) AI systems Regulation (EU) 2024/1689
The Commission would enforce against widespread infringements with a Union dimension, and authorities designated under three other acts would enforce four provisions for the traders those acts cover. The act in pictures

Read Article 30

Recitals

  1. 26
  2. 28
  3. 29
  4. 30
  5. 31
  6. 32
  7. 55
  8. 62
  9. 64
  10. 65
Eureka is adding links and definitions…