Skip to the content
Eureka The Digital Fairness Act Proposal

Topics

Subscriptions, free trials and cancelling

Eureka's summary

Articles 20 to 24 cover contracts with free trial periods, reminders before a contract is automatically extended, an online contract termination function and a withdrawal function. Articles 20 to 22 concern contracts concluded by means of an online interface or by other digital means. Recital 74 says the two functions would not in themselves grant any right to withdraw from or terminate a contract.

Article 20 · Contracts with free trial periods

For contracts with a free trial period concluded by an online interface or other digital means, the trader would have to send the consumer a reminder on a durable medium within a reasonable period before the trial ends. If the reminder is not sent, or the consumer has not expressly agreed before the end of the trial to continue on a paid basis, the consumer would not be bound by the contract.

Free trials: reminder and agreementA timeline, not to scale, for contracts with a free trial period concluded by means of an online interface or by other digital means. Under the proposal the trader would have to send the consumer a reminder on a durable medium within a reasonable period before the end of the trial period (drawn as an envelope with a tick before the end date), stating the end date, the right to terminate and the possibility to continue on a paid basis if the consumer expressly agrees. At the end date the line forks. If the reminder has been sent and the consumer has expressly agreed before the end of the trial, the contract continues as a paid contract and the trader would have to provide a confirmation of that agreement on a durable medium without undue delay and at the latest within a week (second envelope with a tick). If the reminder has not been sent, or the consumer has not expressly agreed, the consumer would not be bound by the contract: either one is enough, drawn as two separate arrows, one from a dashed envelope and one from a dashed speech bubble, to an open chain link. end datefree trialMessage sent Message sent reasonable period before expressly agrees paid contract confirmation within a week Not provided Not provided not bound
Before a free trial ends the trader would have to send a reminder, and the consumer would be bound to a paid contract only after expressly agreeing. The act in pictures

Read Article 20

Article 21 · Reminder before automatic extension of a long-term supply contract

For automatically extended contracts of six months or longer for the continuous supply of products, concluded by an online interface or other digital means, the trader would have to remind the consumer no earlier than 1 month and no later than fourteen days before the extension. Without that reminder, the consumer could terminate free of charge until one is sent. After extension for an indeterminate duration, the consumer could terminate at any time with a maximum one-month notice period.

Long contracts: reminder before extensionThree timelines, not to scale, for a contract for the continuous supply of products with a duration of six months or longer, concluded by means of an online interface or by other digital means, that provides for an automatic extension. First panel: under the proposal the trader would have to remind the consumer on a durable medium, no earlier than 1 month and no later than fourteen days before the date on which the contract is automatically extended, of the upcoming extension and the right to terminate; drawn as an envelope with a tick over a shaded window before the extension. Second panel: where the reminder has not been sent (dashed envelope), the contract is still extended, but the consumer would have the right to terminate free of charge at any time from the date of extension until the date the trader sends a reminder, without any notice period. Third panel: for contracts that have been extended for an indeterminate duration, the consumer would have the right to terminate at any time after the automatic extension with a maximum one-month notice period and free of charge, except for the charges for receiving the product during the notice period; this applies whether or not a reminder was sent. six months or longer automaticextension Message sent Message sent 1 monthfourteen daysbefore Not provided terminatefree of charge indeterminate duration maximum one-monthnotice
For contracts of six months or longer, the trader would have to send a reminder no earlier than 1 month and no later than fourteen days before an automatic extension. The act in pictures

Read Article 21

Article 22 · Reminder before automatic extension of a short-term supply contract

For automatically extended contracts of less than six months for the continuous supply of products, concluded by an online interface or other digital means, a reminder would be due at the latest one week before the extension by which the contract reaches six months or which is the tenth extension, whichever occurs earlier. Without it, the consumer could terminate free of charge until one is sent.

Short contracts: reminder before extensionA timeline, not to scale and without a real number of periods, for a contract for the continuous supply of products with a duration of less than six months, concluded by means of an online interface or by other digital means, that provides for an automatic extension. Under the proposal the trader would have to remind the consumer on a durable medium of the upcoming extension and the right to terminate at the latest one week before the automatic extension which either results in the initial contract duration (or any subsequent extension period) reaching six months or constitutes the tenth extension of the contract, whichever occurs earlier. Drawn as a row of equal periods with two flags, one where the running time reaches six months and one at the tenth extension, a bracket pointing to the earlier flag, and an envelope with a tick one week before it. Which flag comes first depends on the contract; the drawing follows one reading of an unclear sentence. Second panel: where the reminder has not been sent (dashed envelope), the consumer would have the right to terminate free of charge at any time from the date that the reminder was due until the date the trader sends a reminder. A derogation for short-term investment contracts, where the consumer has given explicit consent, is not drawn. whichever occurs earlier reachsix months tenthextensionless than six months Message sent Message sent one week before Not provided terminate free of charge
For contracts of less than six months, a reminder would be due at the latest one week before the extension that reaches six months or is the tenth extension, whichever occurs earlier. The act in pictures

Read Article 22

Article 23 · Online contract termination function

Where a trader offers the possibility of concluding contracts by means of an online interface, consumers would have to be able to terminate the contract through an online contract termination function, irrespective of how it was concluded. The function would be labelled ‘terminate the contract here’ or an unambiguous corresponding formulation. The trader would have to acknowledge receipt on a durable medium at the latest within a week.

Online contract termination functionFour numbered steps. Under the proposal, where a trader offers consumers the possibility of concluding contracts by means of an online interface, the trader would have to ensure that consumers can terminate the contract by using a contract termination function on the online interface, irrespective of the manner in which the contract was concluded. Step 1: the function would be labelled with the words ‘terminate the contract here’ or an unambiguous corresponding formulation, prominently displayed and easily accessible; drawn as a button on a screen, with a tick. Step 2: it would enable the consumer to send an online contract termination statement with the consumer’s name, details identifying the contract, and details of the electronic means by which the acknowledgement will be sent; drawn as a form with three lines. Step 3: the consumer would submit it by means of a confirmation function labelled only with the words ‘confirm the contract termination’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation. Step 4: the trader would have to send the consumer an acknowledgement of receipt on a durable medium without undue delay, and at the latest within a week. The article concerns how to terminate, not whether or when a contract can be ended. if: contracts concluded online 1 terminate the contract here Required 2 Consumer Contract Electronic mail terminationstatement 3 confirm the contract termination 4 Trader Consumer acknowledgement within a week
A trader that lets consumers conclude contracts online would have to offer an online function to terminate them, labelled ‘terminate the contract here’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation. The act in pictures

Read Article 23

Article 24 · Exercise of the right of withdrawal from distance contracts concluded by the means of an online interface

For distance contracts concluded by means of an online interface, including contracts for the supply of financial services, the trader would have to ensure that the consumer can withdraw by using a withdrawal function. It would be labelled ‘withdraw from contract here’ or an unambiguous corresponding formulation and be continuously available during the withdrawal period. The trader would have to acknowledge receipt without undue delay.

Online withdrawal functionFour numbered steps. Under the proposal, for distance contracts within the meaning of Article 2, point (7) of Directive 2011/83/EU, including contracts for the supply of financial services, concluded by means of an online interface, the trader would have to ensure that the consumer can withdraw from the contract by using a withdrawal function. Step 1: the function would be labelled with the words ‘withdraw from contract here’ or an unambiguous corresponding formulation, prominently displayed, easily accessible and continuously available during the withdrawal period; drawn as a button on a screen, with a tick, over a bracket for the withdrawal period. Step 2: it would enable the consumer to send an online withdrawal statement with the consumer’s name, details identifying the contract, and details of the electronic means by which the acknowledgement will be sent; drawn as a form with three lines. Step 3: the consumer would submit it by means of a confirmation function labelled only with the words ‘confirm withdrawal’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation. Step 4: the trader would have to send the consumer an acknowledgement of receipt on a durable medium without undue delay; this article sets no limit in days or weeks. The right of withdrawal and its length come from Directive 2011/83/EU, not from this article. if: distance contracts concluded online 1 withdraw from contract here Required withdrawal period 2 Consumer Contract Electronic mail withdrawalstatement 3 confirm withdrawal 4 Trader Consumer acknowledgementwithout undue delay
For distance contracts concluded online, the trader would have to offer a withdrawal function labelled ‘withdraw from contract here’ or with an unambiguous corresponding formulation, available throughout the withdrawal period. The act in pictures

Read Article 24

Recitals

  1. 69
  2. 70
  3. 71
  4. 72
  5. 73
  6. 74
  7. 75
Eureka is adding links and definitions…